Tigers vs Pirates Prediction MLB Picks for Today 5/17

Tigers vs Pirates Prediction MLB Picks for Today 5/17

© Scott Taetsch-USA TODAY Sports



The highly anticipated clash between the Detroit Tigers and the Pittsburgh Pirates is set to take place on May 17, 2023, at Comerica Park. As we delve into the matchup, we'll analyze each team's pitching and hitting performance, evaluate key injuries, and ultimately explain why the Tigers, led by the formidable Eduardo Rodriguez, have the edge to secure the win.


Pitching Analysis:

For the Pirates, Rich Hill will take the mound. Although Hill has had a decent season with a 3-3 record and a 4.35 ERA, his numbers fall short when compared to the outstanding performance of the Tigers' Eduardo Rodriguez. Rodriguez boasts an impressive 4-2 record, a stellar 1.57 ERA, and a remarkable 0.79 WHIP. With his pinpoint control and ability to miss bats, Rodriguez has proven to be a rock on the mound, making him a formidable force against any lineup.


Hitting Analysis:

Both teams have shown their strengths at the plate, but the Pirates have displayed a slightly better overall performance. Bryan Reynolds has been leading the Pirates' offense with a .293 batting average, .335 on-base percentage, and .500 slugging percentage. Andrew McCutchen has also contributed power, blasting 7 home runs so far this season. On the Tigers' side, Riley Greene has been a consistent presence with a .279 batting average and a .331 on-base percentage. However, the Pirates' offensive prowess could be mitigated by the dominance of Eduardo Rodriguez on the mound.


Injury Update:

In terms of injuries, the Pirates have Rob Zastryzny and Vince Velasquez on the 15-day injured list. While these absences will impact the team, they have shown resilience and depth throughout the season. On the other hand, the Tigers have a few key players on the injured list, including Trey Wingenter, Spencer Turnbull, and Kerry Carpenter. These injuries could potentially hinder the Tigers' performance, but the spotlight remains on their formidable pitching.



Considering the pitching duel between Rich Hill and Eduardo Rodriguez, it becomes evident that the Tigers hold a significant advantage. Rodriguez's stellar season, with his remarkable ERA and WHIP, indicates that he will likely stifle the Pirates' offense. Moreover, the Tigers have shown resilience at home, with a 9-9 record, while the Pirates have struggled on the road, sitting at 12-10 away from home.

The Tigers' hitters will have a tough task against Hill, but with Rodriguez's dominance on the mound, they should find enough run support to secure the win. The Pirates, despite their solid performance at the plate, will struggle against the Tigers' ace left-hander.

In conclusion, with Rodriguez's outstanding performance on the mound, the Tigers have the edge in this matchup. Expect a hard-fought game, but ultimately, the Tigers will prevail over the Pirates, setting the stage for an exciting showdown between these two competitive teams.

Pick: Tigers ML

Upgrade to View Prediction
Winnings $74,767
last 30 days winnings $19,620
Yesterday winnings $0
Top Sport MLB
W-L-D 386 - 248 - 8
Winnings % 59%
Winnings $79,704
last 30 days winnings $12,300
Yesterday winnings $0
Top Sport NCAAB
W-L-D 241 - 147 - 5
Winnings % 61%
Winnings $75,450
last 30 days winnings ($4,690)
Yesterday winnings ($1,310)
Top Sport NBA
W-L-D 678 - 457 - 13
Winnings % 58%