Kingpin analysis
Clarke Schmidt MLB Player Prop for Yankees vs Guardians G3 10/17

© Peter Aiken-Imagn Images
Clarke Schmidt MLB Player Prop: ALCS Game 3 - Yankees vs Guardians
The New York Yankees lead the Cleveland Guardians 2-0 in the ALCS as Game 3 heads to Progressive Field in Cleveland. Clarke Schmidt will be taking the mound for the Yankees, and his hits allowed prop is set at 3.5 (-145). We'll analyze Schmidt's recent performance and matchup against the Guardians' hitters to assess whether backing the over Zor under on this prop offers value.
Game Odds
| Team | Moneyline | Run Line | Over/Under |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York Yankees (94-68) | -120 | -1.5 (+160) | Over 7.5 (+115) |
| Cleveland Guardians (92-69) | -110 | +1.5 (-190) | Under 7.5 (-135) |
The Yankees are slight favorites going into Game 3, looking to take a commanding 3-0 series lead. With a total set at 7.5 runs, the game projects to be relatively low-scoring, which influences the outlook on Schmidt’s pitching performance.
Team Analysis
New York Yankees
The Yankees have dominated the first two games of the ALCS, winning 5-2 and 6-3. Clarke Schmidt, their starting pitcher for Game 3, had a solid regular season with a 2.85 ERA, 93 strikeouts, and a 1.18 WHIP over 85.1 innings. Schmidt allowed 71 hits across those innings, giving him an average of 7.5 hits allowed per 9 innings.
Cleveland Guardians
The Guardians will look to bounce back in Game 3 at home. Cleveland's offense, anchored by hitters like Jose Ramirez and Steven Kwan, has shown the ability to make contact, especially against pitchers like Schmidt. Ramirez has gone 4-for-9 against Schmidt in his career, and Kwan has posted a .500 average in his limited at-bats against the Yankees right-hander.
Clarke Schmidt’s Recent Performance
Schmidt’s recent games have shown a mix of solid outings and struggles, particularly with hit prevention:
- October 9 vs. Kansas City (ALDS Game 1): 4.2 innings, 4 hits allowed, 2 earned runs.
- September 29 vs. Pittsburgh: 4.0 innings, 3 hits allowed, 4 earned runs.
- September 19 vs. Seattle: 5.0 innings, 6 hits allowed, 1 earned run.
- September 13 vs. Boston: 5.2 innings, 5 hits allowed, 2 earned runs.
In his last four starts, Schmidt has allowed at least 3 hits in each appearance and surpassed 3.5 hits in three of those games. With Schmidt not typically going deep into games, his shorter outings still tend to involve allowing a few hits early on.
Guardians Hitters vs. Clarke Schmidt
Schmidt will face a Cleveland lineup that has had some success against him in the past. Key matchups include:
- Steven Kwan: 4-for-8 (.500), 2 strikeouts
- Jose Ramirez: 4-for-9 (.444), 2 RBIs
- Andres Gimenez: 5-for-10 (.500), 1 RBI
With multiple Cleveland hitters having strong averages against Schmidt, it increases the likelihood of them collecting hits off the Yankees right-hander, especially in front of a home crowd in a must-win situation.
Betting Stats and Trends
- Clarke Schmidt hits allowed prop: Schmidt has given up more than 3.5 hits in three of his last four starts.
- Yankees road performance: The Yankees have been strong on the road, but their pitchers have allowed an average of 8.1 hits per game when away from Yankee Stadium.
- Guardians home performance: Cleveland’s offense improves at home, where they bat .252 compared to their overall average of .238.
Prediction
Clarke Schmidt has consistently allowed hits in his recent outings, and with a Guardians lineup that features hitters who have performed well against him in the past, the over 3.5 hits allowed prop at -145 seems like a solid wager. Schmidt is unlikely to pitch deep into the game, but Cleveland’s contact-heavy approach could lead to several early hits.
Pick: Clarke Schmidt to allow over 3.5 hits (-145). With Cleveland's offense facing a must-win situation, expect them to be aggressive and rack up a few hits off Schmidt early in the game.
Kingpin PRO
Get ranked cards and line-move alerts in the app
Tracked experts, Edge scores, and alerts on iPhone and Android.
Simulated results. Entertainment only. Gambling involves risk.Methodology and disclosure
Historical Kingpin articles preserve original body copy, authors, and publication dates. Structured pick or odds modules appear only when the source article provides them.
Kingpin PRO
Track this game in the Kingpin app
Transparent simulated records. Entertainment only.
Simulated results. Entertainment only. Gambling involves risk.Simulated results for entertainment. Gambling involves risk. Bet only where legal.
