Kingpin analysis
NFL Week 1 Predictions: Buffalo Bills vs Arizona Cardinals 9/8

© Jamie Germano/Democrat and Chronicle / USA TODAY NETWORK
NFL Week 1: Buffalo Bills vs. Arizona Cardinals Preview and Prediction
Introduction
The 2024 NFL season kicks off with an intriguing matchup as the Buffalo Bills host the Arizona Cardinals at Highmark Stadium on September 8th. The Bills, who have been consistent playoff contenders in recent years, enter this game as -6.5 point favorites. Meanwhile, the Cardinals are in the midst of a rebuild and are looking to establish themselves under a new regime. With the over/under set at 48.5 points, this game will be a test of Buffalo's high-powered offense against Arizona's young and unproven defense.
Game Odds
Odds by ESPN BET as of 10:00 AM
| Team | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona Cardinals (0-0) | +6.5 (-105) | o48.5 (-105) | +240 |
| Buffalo Bills (0-0) | -6.5 (-115) | u48.5 (-115) | -290 |
Team Overview
Buffalo Bills
The Buffalo Bills come into the 2024 season with high expectations. Under head coach Sean McDermott, the Bills have developed into one of the most well-rounded teams in the NFL, consistently boasting a strong defense and an explosive offense. Quarterback Mitchell Trubisky, who took over the starting role this season, is under pressure to fill the shoes left by Josh Allen. Although Trubisky’s preseason performances have been mixed, his experience and the weapons around him provide a solid foundation.
Buffalo’s offense, led by veteran wide receiver Stefon Diggs and young playmaker Dalton Kincaid, is built to stretch the field. Running back Frank Gore Jr., who had a productive preseason, will look to establish the ground game, complementing the passing attack. The offensive line, despite some preseason struggles, remains capable of giving Trubisky the protection he needs to operate efficiently.
Defensively, the Bills continue to be a formidable unit. Despite losing linebacker Matt Milano to injury, the defense remains anchored by a strong secondary led by Tre'Davious White. The pass rush, bolstered by the addition of rookie Javon Solomon, will aim to disrupt the Cardinals' young quarterback. The Bills' defense will be crucial in setting the tone early, especially against a Cardinals team that has struggled offensively in the preseason.
Arizona Cardinals
The Arizona Cardinals enter the 2024 season as a team in transition. Under the new leadership of head coach Jonathan Gannon, the Cardinals are rebuilding with a focus on developing young talent. Rookie quarterback Clayton Tune has shown flashes of potential, but his preseason performance has been inconsistent. Tune’s ability to adapt to the NFL's speed and complexity will be a key factor in the Cardinals' success this season.
On offense, the Cardinals lack star power, with their top receiver, Xavier Weaver, questionable for this game due to injury. Running back Tavion Benson will need to carry a significant load, especially against a tough Bills defense. The offensive line, which has been a weak point for Arizona, will face a stern test against Buffalo’s pass rush.
Defensively, the Cardinals are a work in progress. The secondary, already weakened by injuries, will be challenged by Buffalo’s dynamic passing attack. The front seven, led by defensive end Darius Robinson, must find ways to pressure Trubisky and disrupt the Bills' offense. However, with several key players on injured reserve, Arizona’s defense could be in for a long day.
Recent Performance
The Bills had a mixed preseason, finishing with a 1-2 record. Their final preseason game, a 31-26 loss to the Carolina Panthers, highlighted some areas of concern, particularly on defense where they struggled to contain the run. Mitchell Trubisky’s performance was also under scrutiny, as he threw an interception and failed to lead the offense consistently. However, the Bills showed flashes of their potential, particularly in their second preseason game against the Pittsburgh Steelers, where the defense was dominant in a 9-3 victory.
The Cardinals, on the other hand, had a disappointing preseason, finishing 0-3. Their most recent game, a 38-12 loss to the Denver Broncos, exposed significant weaknesses, particularly in their defense and offensive line. Clayton Tune, while showing moments of promise, struggled with consistency, throwing for just one touchdown against two interceptions across the preseason. Arizona's inability to sustain drives and protect the quarterback was a recurring issue that they will need to address quickly as the regular season begins.
Head-to-Head Comparison
When comparing these two teams, the Buffalo Bills have a clear advantage in several key areas. Offensively, the Bills possess a more experienced and explosive unit, with Mitchell Trubisky, despite his recent struggles, offering more stability than the Cardinals' rookie quarterback Clayton Tune. Buffalo’s receiving corps, featuring Stefon Diggs, has the potential to exploit Arizona’s weakened secondary.
In the running game, the Bills also have the edge. Frank Gore Jr. showed in the preseason that he can be a workhorse back, while the Cardinals’ Tavion Benson is still unproven at the NFL level. The Bills' offensive line, while not without its issues, is more reliable than the Cardinals', which has been a point of concern throughout the preseason.
Defensively, the Bills have a significant advantage, particularly in the secondary. Tre'Davious White and Micah Hyde lead a unit that should be able to contain Arizona’s receiving threats, especially with Xavier Weaver questionable. The Bills' pass rush, bolstered by Javon Solomon, will look to exploit the Cardinals’ suspect offensive line, putting pressure on the rookie quarterback and forcing mistakes.
Key Injuries and Their Impact
Injuries could play a significant role in this matchup. For the Bills, the most concerning injury is to quarterback Mitchell Trubisky, who is questionable for the game. If Trubisky is unable to play, the Bills will need to turn to their backup, which could limit their offensive potential. Additionally, the loss of linebacker Matt Milano for the season weakens Buffalo’s defense, particularly in pass coverage.
The Cardinals are dealing with several injuries, most notably to wide receiver Xavier Weaver and tight end Tip Reiman, both of whom are questionable. Weaver's absence would leave a significant void in Arizona's already thin receiving corps. The loss of offensive tackle Christian Jones, who is on injured reserve, further exacerbates the Cardinals’ offensive line issues, which could be a major problem against Buffalo’s pass rush.
Coaching Matchup
The coaching matchup pits Buffalo’s seasoned head coach Sean McDermott against Arizona’s new head coach Jonathan Gannon. McDermott, who has led the Bills to multiple playoff appearances, is known for his defensive acumen and ability to get the most out of his players. His experience and familiarity with his team give the Bills a significant advantage in this matchup.
Gannon, on the other hand, is entering his first season as a head coach after serving as the defensive coordinator for the Philadelphia Eagles. He faces the challenge of implementing a new system and culture in Arizona, which is always a tough task for a rookie head coach. Gannon’s defensive background will be tested against Buffalo’s potent offense, and how he adjusts during the game will be critical to the Cardinals’ chances of competing.
Advanced Metrics and Key Stats
Advanced metrics highlight the disparity between these two teams. Last season, the Bills ranked in the top ten in both offensive and defensive efficiency, showcasing their balance on both sides of the ball. Buffalo’s offense was particularly effective in the red zone, converting a high percentage of their opportunities into touchdowns, which will be crucial against a Cardinals defense that struggled in the red zone last season.
Defensively, the Bills excelled at forcing turnovers, ranking among the league leaders in takeaways. Their ability to generate pressure and create turnovers will be key against a Cardinals offense that has been prone to mistakes. On the other hand, the Cardinals ranked near the bottom of the league in several key metrics last season, including third-down conversion percentage and yards per play allowed, reflecting their struggles on both sides of the ball.
The key statistical battle in this game will likely be turnovers and third-down efficiency. The Bills’ ability to capitalize on Arizona’s mistakes and extend drives on third down could be the difference in the game. If the Cardinals cannot improve in these areas, they will have a hard time keeping up with Buffalo’s well-rounded attack.
Weather and Venue Impact
The weather in Orchard Park for this Week 1 matchup is expected to be mild, with temperatures around 65 degrees and no significant chance of rain. These conditions are ideal for football and should not have a major impact on the game. However, the atmosphere at Highmark Stadium, known for its passionate and vocal fans, could play a role, especially with the Bills playing their home opener. The crowd noise could make it difficult for the Cardinals, particularly with a rookie quarterback at the helm, to communicate effectively on offense.
Buffalo has a strong home-field advantage, and playing in front of their fans will provide an extra boost. The Cardinals, on the other hand, will need to overcome the challenges of playing on the road in a hostile environment, which could be a significant factor if they fall behind early.
Betting Trends and Statistics
The betting trends favor the Buffalo Bills in this matchup. The Bills have been strong against the spread at home, covering in six of their last eight games at Highmark Stadium. As favorites, Buffalo has also performed well, particularly when favored by a touchdown or more. Additionally, the Bills have a history of starting strong in season openers, which bodes well for their chances of covering the spread.
The Cardinals, on the other hand, have struggled against the spread, particularly as underdogs. Arizona is just 1-5 ATS in their last six games as road underdogs, and they have also struggled in season openers, covering the spread in only one of their last four Week 1 games. With a young and inexperienced team, the Cardinals could have a tough time keeping this game close.
The total for this game is set at 48.5 points. The over has been a common trend in games involving the Bills, particularly at home where the over has hit in four of their last six games. However, the Cardinals have seen the under hit in five of their last seven road games, reflecting their struggles on offense. Bettors will need to consider whether Buffalo’s offense will push the total over or if Arizona’s defense can keep the game within reach.
Player Spotlight: Mitchell Trubisky
All eyes will be on Mitchell Trubisky as he steps into the starting quarterback role for the Buffalo Bills. Trubisky, a former first-round pick, has had an up-and-down career but now has an opportunity to lead a talented Bills roster. His performance in this game will be critical, as the Bills look to start the season on a strong note.
Trubisky’s ability to manage the game and avoid turnovers will be key. He has a solid supporting cast, with Stefon Diggs as his primary target and Frank Gore Jr. providing balance in the running game. Trubisky’s mobility will also be a factor, as he can extend plays and create opportunities with his legs. However, he will need to be sharp against an Arizona defense that, while inexperienced, has the potential to disrupt his rhythm.
The pressure is on Trubisky to deliver, and how he handles the expectations will be a major storyline in this game. If he can play efficiently and lead the Bills to a convincing win, it will go a long way in establishing his credibility as the team’s starting quarterback.
Prediction
The Buffalo Bills enter this game as strong favorites, and they have the talent and experience to justify that position. Buffalo’s offense, led by Mitchell Trubisky, should have little trouble moving the ball against a Cardinals defense that is still finding its footing. The Bills’ defense, meanwhile, should be able to contain Arizona’s young offense and force them into mistakes. While the Cardinals may show flashes of potential, Buffalo’s superiority on both sides of the ball should allow them to cover the spread comfortably.
Pick: Buffalo Bills -6.5
Kingpin PRO
Follow ranked bettors with tracked cards
This article is free analysis. PRO unlocks today’s verified bettor inventory and alerts.
Simulated results. Entertainment only. Gambling involves risk.Methodology and disclosure
Historical Kingpin articles preserve original body copy, authors, and publication dates. Structured pick or odds modules appear only when the source article provides them.
Kingpin PRO
Continue with Kingpin PRO
Transparent simulated records. Entertainment only.
Simulated results. Entertainment only. Gambling involves risk.Simulated results for entertainment. Gambling involves risk. Bet only where legal.